| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3027 |
From: Ball, Gordon [Sec Div] |
Date: 05/11/2010 |
| Subject: See you there this weekend! |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3028 |
From: David Halfpenny (y) |
Date: 07/11/2010 |
| Subject: Re: See you there this weekend! |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3029 |
From: Silver_Dream_Racer |
Date: 08/11/2010 |
| Subject: APT-E Record breakers Weekend. |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3030 |
From: David Halfpenny (y) |
Date: 08/11/2010 |
| Subject: Re: APT-E Record breakers Weekend. |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3031 |
From: Ball, Gordon [Sec Div] |
Date: 08/11/2010 |
| Subject: Hidden APT power car down the back at Shildon |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3032 |
From: David Halfpenny (y) |
Date: 08/11/2010 |
| Subject: Re: Hidden APT power car down the back at Shildon |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3034 |
From: Silver_Dream_Racer |
Date: 08/11/2010 |
| Subject: APT-E record breakers cab-it weekend report |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3035 |
From: Silver_Dream_Racer |
Date: 09/11/2010 |
| Subject: Re: Hidden APT power car down the back at Shildon |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3036 |
From: misterrtilt |
Date: 09/11/2010 |
| Subject: Re: Hidden APT power car down the back at Shildon |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3037 |
From: David Halfpenny (y) |
Date: 10/11/2010 |
| Subject: Re: Hidden APT power car down the back at Shildon |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3038 |
From: misterrtilt |
Date: 10/11/2010 |
| Subject: Re: Hidden APT power car down the back at Shildon |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3039 |
From: Silver_Dream_Racer |
Date: 17/11/2010 |
| Subject: Calling Hugh Williams................... |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3040 |
From: Anthony |
Date: 19/11/2010 |
| Subject: Re: Hidden APT power car down the back at Shildon |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3041 |
From: Advanced-Passenger-Train-owner@yahoogroup |
Date: 26/12/2010 |
| Subject: Seasons greetings |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3042 |
From: Jack The Gunner |
Date: 26/12/2010 |
| Subject: Re: Seasons greetings |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3043 |
From: Silver_Dream_Racer |
Date: 02/01/2011 |
| Subject: A APT-E Happy New Year................... |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3044 |
From: Nick Wheat |
Date: 02/01/2011 |
| Subject: Re: A APT-E Happy New Year................... |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3045 |
From: Silver_Dream_Racer |
Date: 03/01/2011 |
| Subject: Re: A APT-E Happy New Year................... |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3046 |
From: misterrtilt |
Date: 18/01/2011 |
| Subject: Hastings Coach moving |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3047 |
From: Paul Rowlinson |
Date: 18/01/2011 |
| Subject: Re: Hastings Coach moving |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3048 |
From: Gerry Bates |
Date: 18/01/2011 |
| Subject: Re: Hastings Coach moving |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3049 |
From: Silver_Dream_Racer |
Date: 19/01/2011 |
| Subject: Re: Hastings Coach moving |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3050 |
From: t.sage |
Date: 19/01/2011 |
| Subject: Re: Hastings Coach moving |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3051 |
From: misterrtilt |
Date: 20/01/2011 |
| Subject: Re: Hastings Coach moving |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3052 |
From: shane.wilton |
Date: 20/01/2011 |
| Subject: Re: Hastings Coach moving |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3053 |
From: Silver_Dream_Racer |
Date: 26/01/2011 |
| Subject: June 11th 2011 - An important Event. |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3054 |
From: brookweed5@aol.com |
Date: 26/01/2011 |
| Subject: Re: June 11th 2011 - An important Event. |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3055 |
From: Silver_Dream_Racer |
Date: 26/01/2011 |
| Subject: Re: June 11th 2011 - An important Event. |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3056 |
From: misterrtilt |
Date: 27/01/2011 |
| Subject: Re: June 11th 2011 - An important Event. |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3057 |
From: Silver_Dream_Racer |
Date: 05/02/2011 |
| Subject: A date to remember APT fans. |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3058 |
From: eth1607688@aol.com |
Date: 05/02/2011 |
| Subject: Re: June 11th 2011 - An important Event. |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3059 |
From: Silver_Dream_Racer |
Date: 05/02/2011 |
| Subject: Re: June 11th 2011 - An important Event. |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3060 |
From: Howard Sprenger |
Date: 15/02/2011 |
| Subject: Fw: [MRSOC] APT |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3061 |
From: misterrtilt |
Date: 16/02/2011 |
| Subject: Re: Fw: [MRSOC] APT |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3062 |
From: SPRENGER HOWARD |
Date: 16/02/2011 |
| Subject: Re: Fw: [MRSOC] APT |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3063 |
From: Silver_Dream_Racer |
Date: 16/02/2011 |
| Subject: APT-E Workday Dates Announced............... |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3064 |
From: Gerry Bates |
Date: 16/02/2011 |
| Subject: Fwd: Re: APT |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3065 |
From: Howard Sprenger |
Date: 16/02/2011 |
| Subject: Re: Fwd: Re: APT |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3066 |
From: aptp370 |
Date: 19/02/2011 |
| Subject: BEFORE APT ? |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3067 |
From: Silver_Dream_Racer |
Date: 02/03/2011 |
| Subject: Workday 5th March 2011 APT-E |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3068 |
From: Arlen Andra S Bone |
Date: 04/03/2011 |
| Subject: Re: APT-E modelling |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3069 |
From: Alan Coombe |
Date: 04/03/2011 |
| Subject: Re: APT-E modelling |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3070 |
From: aptp370 |
Date: 04/03/2011 |
| Subject: Re: APT-E modelling |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3071 |
From: Nigel Richards |
Date: 04/03/2011 |
| Subject: Re: APT-E modelling |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3072 |
From: Adam Warr |
Date: 04/03/2011 |
| Subject: Re: APT-E modelling |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3073 |
From: shane.wilton |
Date: 05/03/2011 |
| Subject: Re: APT-E modelling |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3074 |
From: misterrtilt |
Date: 05/03/2011 |
| Subject: Re: APT-E modelling |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3075 |
From: Silver_Dream_Racer |
Date: 06/03/2011 |
| Subject: APT-E Work Day Report For The 5th March 2011. |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3076 |
From: Alan Coombe |
Date: 06/03/2011 |
| Subject: Re: APT-E modelling |
|
| Group: Advanced-Passenger-Train |
Message: 3077 |
From: Paul Rowlinson |
Date: 07/03/2011 |
| Subject: Re: APT-E modelling |
|
Jeepers, so many people wanting to model E-Train! Amazing.....
Numerous points arise after reading the thread, so this reply could go on a bit.
Firstly, the train was hardly ever the same from one test run to the next, so no drawings are ever going to show it 100% correct, only as it was on one particular day. However, as it still exists almost any problem can be solved by going to Shildon and looking and measuring. OK, so that means you'd end up modelling it as it is right NOW, but 99% of people won't know it any other way, will they? That goes for everyone else modelling it too, plans aren't the be-all and end-all of what the train looked like really.
As for rivets, only the Trailer Cars have visible rivets, the Power Cars are flush riveted, but do show panel lines where the various skin panels join up. In most cases the TC rivets are around 4-5 mm in dia. at most, and less than 3 mm high, so highly visible they aren't, especially in N gauge!
I made my N gauge E-Train (STILL unfinshed after umpteen years....) from sheet styrene over styrene bulkheads, but I made no attempt to make the vehicles tilt. I used bogies from an N gauge Ibertren RENFE Talgo train, which had it's diaphragm type joint modules mounted on the bogies themselves. These aren't exact copies of E-Train JMs, but can be made to look almost like them, plus they have the swivel joint system built into the joint modules, which makes life easier.
For my power bogie, and remember the real train only has drive on four axles, I used a Minitrix Class 33 bogie with the motor replaced by an ECM Type 1 motor, their smallest. I have no doubt that many smaller motors are available nowadays, and hopefully you won't have to file off the corners of the motor casing as I had to!
My power car nose was made the same way as the body shell, styrene sheet cut to shape, glued up and then much PSR work (= Putty, Sand, Repeat....) till it looked right. It's not that difficult a shape to make, believe me.
On the mirrored windows, E-Train always had mirrored windows on both trailer cars from the first run, but TC1 ONLY has them on the VIP compartment end, not on the end toward PC1. We had seats fitted in the VIP compartment from the start too, but no trim or carpets were fitted before Rebuild 1. The mirrored look comes from a thin plastic sheet on the inside of the inner window panes, just like a custom car. But if you'd like people to see the inside why not mirror one side and leave the other clear? People can only see one side at a time remember. You could even build one side of one power car 'de-skinned' too, but rather you than me making all the bits and pieces inside there!
Changing to other's comments, I would imagine there's NO chance of Bachmann making an E-Train. We've had this loads of times before, and while everyone here is a big APT fan, by definition, the big markets for manufacturers are all nhard-over steam and diesel nuts. Most of them think APT was a 'dead end train that made people sick' to this day.
As for Shane's etched brass POP Train, you sir are totally deranged! <g>
Deranged but amazingly skillfull, that looks SO much like the real thing it brought back wonderful memories, especially the end-on views of your model, it was just like the view I had from the opposite car when we were on a test run.
Having built a steering beam for the SA bogie you're half way to an E1T anyway, as the steering beam was the same on both bogie designs. Indeed they were the SAME steering beams, the ones that still support the train to this day.
Hope that lot helps some anyway.
Regards
Kit
--- In Advanced-Passenger-Train@yahoogroups.com, Arlen Andra S Bone <arlenbone@...> wrote:
>
> Hi
> I am a big fan of the APT-E and a number of years ago attended a couple of the conservation and support work days at the NRM. I am interested in making a model of the train and would like to know where I can get hold of some accurate (and preferably large scale) design drawings for the train. I would like to make models of both the TCs and the power car in order to create moulds so that more cast resin vehicles can be made. I am also interested in creating a bogie design that can utilise a system of ramps to tilt the vehicles when they go into a curve -just like hornby did on their P-train model.
>
> I can see that building a model of E train would be somewhat fraut with practical issues if one were to attempt to model each and every rivet in a small scale such
> as N gauge. I'm doubtful whether it would be possible to reproduce the same level of rivet detail that is visible on Dapol's excellent class 153! A lot of real life rail vehicles do indeed have a lot of rivet detail and I am interested in finding out more about the level of rivet detail possible in n-scale etched brass kits -just to see what level of detail could be remoulded. -I have been thinking about buying myself an MSL hobbies EM2 kit, partially 'cos I also like Woodhead locos -but also to see how the many of the rivets of those prototypes are reproduced on their etched brass kit, if at all, -and to see how satisfactory the overall effect is in N gauge, with or without full rivet detail. Similarly I'm interested in seeing the level of detailing possible Re: grilles etc. that is possible in N gauge. -So I can ascertain the best mode of construction / materials etc for my initial model. (probably either plasticard / brass -with embedded grilles
> constructed from strip styrene.)
>
> I'm aware that there's a company that does N scale transfers for E-train (and also for p-train -and also for a whole myriad of RTC test vehicles) -so at least that aspect of the modelling shouldn't prove too hard.
>
> constructing / carving a half decent nose for the initial model / mould might be tricky!
>
> And then there's the issue of bogies. I think I'd need a lot of drawings to construct these -and possibly a number of proprietary parts to detail them.
>
> given the fact I'd be creating an articulated train, motorising the train might prove difficult. I think it would be feasible to motorise the leading bogies somehow - modifying an existing 4 wheel chassis to incorporate a ramp based tilt system. The fact one would need to construct artic bogies that are joined onto the shared doors -and also somehow engage the 'ramps' that tilt the train would be very difficult indeed - nevertheless I
> think that it would still be possible.
>
> I'm aware of how E-Train has mirrored windows. Was this done with a painted or spraypainted on solution -or was it done with mirror film? I have managed to find a number of manufacturers of mirrored plastic sheet that could be used for this purpose -and one that even makes 2 way mirror plastic sheet! -However I am actually interested in creating a rudimentary interior for my model -including the various partitions etc -and possibly even the VIP lounge! If E-train ever ran without the mirrors I'd love to know -becuase I wouldn't mind making the interiors visible. Was the VIP lounge incorporated in the train before or after the windows were mirrored -or were the seats put in at the same time?
>
> If anybody can help me to get hold of some photocopies / scans of some accurate plans I'd therefore be very very grateful.
>
> thanks Arlen Bone
>
>
|
|
|
Shane
As you are modelling in 4mm, you may be interested in some 4mm whitemetal castings I had done for the E-train many years ago. These were for the axlebox assembly
and were designed to fix to the frames above with real springs. As I no longer model in 4mm having moved to O Gauge, I no longer have need of these.
On the other hand I wonder if your steering beam will scale up to 7mm?
If you want to contact me off group w might be able to come to an arrangement!
regards
Paul Rowlinson
Head of Operations, London
Sanctuary Management Services
Dinwiddy House, 189-205 Pentonville Road,
London, N1 9NF
Tel: 0207 812 0022
Mob: 07787 834807
Sanctuary Management Services is part of Sanctuary Group
paul.rowlinson@...
From: Advanced-Passenger-Train@yahoogroups.com [mailto:Advanced-Passenger-Train@yahoogroups.com]
On Behalf Of misterrtilt
Sent: 05 March 2011 13:10
To: Advanced-Passenger-Train@yahoogroups.com
Subject: <APT Group> Re: APT-E modelling
Jeepers, so many people wanting to model E-Train! Amazing.....
Numerous points arise after reading the thread, so this reply could go on a bit.
Firstly, the train was hardly ever the same from one test run to the next, so no drawings are ever going to show it 100% correct, only as it was on one particular day. However, as it still exists almost any problem can be solved by going to Shildon and looking
and measuring. OK, so that means you'd end up modelling it as it is right NOW, but 99% of people won't know it any other way, will they? That goes for everyone else modelling it too, plans aren't the be-all and end-all of what the train looked like really.
As for rivets, only the Trailer Cars have visible rivets, the Power Cars are flush riveted, but do show panel lines where the various skin panels join up. In most cases the TC rivets are around 4-5 mm in dia. at most, and less than 3 mm high, so highly visible
they aren't, especially in N gauge!
I made my N gauge E-Train (STILL unfinshed after umpteen years....) from sheet styrene over styrene bulkheads, but I made no attempt to make the vehicles tilt. I used bogies from an N gauge Ibertren RENFE Talgo train, which had it's diaphragm type joint modules
mounted on the bogies themselves. These aren't exact copies of E-Train JMs, but can be made to look almost like them, plus they have the swivel joint system built into the joint modules, which makes life easier.
For my power bogie, and remember the real train only has drive on four axles, I used a Minitrix Class 33 bogie with the motor replaced by an ECM Type 1 motor, their smallest. I have no doubt that many smaller motors are available nowadays, and hopefully you
won't have to file off the corners of the motor casing as I had to!
My power car nose was made the same way as the body shell, styrene sheet cut to shape, glued up and then much PSR work (= Putty, Sand, Repeat....) till it looked right. It's not that difficult a shape to make, believe me.
On the mirrored windows, E-Train always had mirrored windows on both trailer cars from the first run, but TC1 ONLY has them on the VIP compartment end, not on the end toward PC1. We had seats fitted in the VIP compartment from the start too, but no trim or
carpets were fitted before Rebuild 1. The mirrored look comes from a thin plastic sheet on the inside of the inner window panes, just like a custom car. But if you'd like people to see the inside why not mirror one side and leave the other clear? People can
only see one side at a time remember. You could even build one side of one power car 'de-skinned' too, but rather you than me making all the bits and pieces inside there!
Changing to other's comments, I would imagine there's NO chance of Bachmann making an E-Train. We've had this loads of times before, and while everyone here is a big APT fan, by definition, the big markets for manufacturers are all nhard-over steam and diesel
nuts. Most of them think APT was a 'dead end train that made people sick' to this day.
As for Shane's etched brass POP Train, you sir are totally deranged! <g>
Deranged but amazingly skillfull, that looks SO much like the real thing it brought back wonderful memories, especially the end-on views of your model, it was just like the view I had from the opposite car when we were on a test run.
Having built a steering beam for the SA bogie you're half way to an E1T anyway, as the steering beam was the same on both bogie designs. Indeed they were the SAME steering beams, the ones that still support the train to this day.
Hope that lot helps some anyway.
Regards
Kit
--- In Advanced-Passenger-Train@yahoogroups.com, Arlen Andra S Bone <arlenbone@...> wrote:
>
> Hi
> I am a big fan of the APT-E and a number of years ago attended a couple of the conservation and support work days at the NRM. I am interested in making a model of the train and would like to know where I can get hold of some accurate (and preferably large
scale) design drawings for the train. I would like to make models of both the TCs and the power car in order to create moulds so that more cast resin vehicles can be made. I am also interested in creating a bogie design that can utilise a system of ramps to
tilt the vehicles when they go into a curve -just like hornby did on their P-train model.
>
> I can see that building a model of E train would be somewhat fraut with practical issues if one were to attempt to model each and every rivet in a small scale such
> as N gauge. I'm doubtful whether it would be possible to reproduce the same level of rivet detail that is visible on Dapol's excellent class 153! A lot of real life rail vehicles do indeed have a lot of rivet detail and I am interested in finding out more
about the level of rivet detail possible in n-scale etched brass kits -just to see what level of detail could be remoulded. -I have been thinking about buying myself an MSL hobbies EM2 kit, partially 'cos I also like Woodhead locos -but also to see how the
many of the rivets of those prototypes are reproduced on their etched brass kit, if at all, -and to see how satisfactory the overall effect is in N gauge, with or without full rivet detail. Similarly I'm interested in seeing the level of detailing possible
Re: grilles etc. that is possible in N gauge. -So I can ascertain the best mode of construction / materials etc for my initial model. (probably either plasticard / brass -with embedded grilles
> constructed from strip styrene.)
>
> I'm aware that there's a company that does N scale transfers for E-train (and also for p-train -and also for a whole myriad of RTC test vehicles) -so at least that aspect of the modelling shouldn't prove too hard.
>
> constructing / carving a half decent nose for the initial model / mould might be tricky!
>
> And then there's the issue of bogies. I think I'd need a lot of drawings to construct these -and possibly a number of proprietary parts to detail them.
>
> given the fact I'd be creating an articulated train, motorising the train might prove difficult. I think it would be feasible to motorise the leading bogies somehow - modifying an existing 4 wheel chassis to incorporate a ramp based tilt system. The fact
one would need to construct artic bogies that are joined onto the shared doors -and also somehow engage the 'ramps' that tilt the train would be very difficult indeed - nevertheless I
> think that it would still be possible.
>
> I'm aware of how E-Train has mirrored windows. Was this done with a painted or spraypainted on solution -or was it done with mirror film? I have managed to find a number of manufacturers of mirrored plastic sheet that could be used for this purpose -and one
that even makes 2 way mirror plastic sheet! -However I am actually interested in creating a rudimentary interior for my model -including the various partitions etc -and possibly even the VIP lounge! If E-train ever ran without the mirrors I'd love to know
-becuase I wouldn't mind making the interiors visible. Was the VIP lounge incorporated in the train before or after the windows were mirrored -or were the seats put in at the same time?
>
> If anybody can help me to get hold of some photocopies / scans of some accurate plans I'd therefore be very very grateful.
>
> thanks Arlen Bone
>
>
Click
here to report this email as spam to Sanctuary's managed spam filter, Websense Hosted Security. (Do NOT click on 'remove me' or other links from spam as that may confirm your email to the spam sender or lead to malicious websites)
|
Sanctuary Housing Association: Email Disclaimer |
This email, and any files transmitted within it, is confidential and intended solely for the use of the individual or entity to whom it is addressed.
If you have received this email in error, please notify Sanctuary Housing Association on +44 (0)845 373 3883 or email postmaster@...
This message has been scanned for computer viruses. However, it is the responsibility of the recipient to ensure that it is virus free before using it and no responsibility whatsoever is accepted by Sanctuary Housing Association for any loss or damage arising in any way from its use.
Registered as a Social Landlord with the Tenant Services Authority - No. L0247. Industrial & Provident Society No. 19059R.
|
|
|